Is it possible to have love for all women?

Is it possible to have love for all women yet settle down with only one? I love all women but it seems like only certain women love me. Don't get me wrong I am not a dog or a pig. I just think all souls are beautiful and they illuminate me. Unfortunately that makes me suspicious to most women. When I am in a relationship I only invest my energy in the woman I am with though and not other women. I do believe in commitment and that is a huge value for me. Maybe relationships aren't as much about love as it is compatibility? Like I am saying I love all women and I am very respectful of the woman I am with but normally it turns out that the girl ends up not liking me. I think it is because I tend to pick out girls who like me at first but then push me away when I don't fit into their crowd of friends or whatever. So I think it is more of their own insecurity issue. What do you think? Do you love all women/men yet respect your lover and the boundaries of a relationship?